Stop the Treasury Estate Tax Hike
The Department of Treasury recently proposed changes to Section 2704 estate and gift tax valuation discounts which will increase the tax burden on many family run businesses, making it harder for family owned and operated businesses to transition to the next generation.
About Valuation Discounts
Valuing a family business for the purposes of estate and gift taxes can be difficult due to the lack of an identifiable market for the business. The valuation is further complicated when the IRS does its own valuation at tax time. For families trying to pass a family-held business on to the next generation there are several valuation discounts available to protect a business’s assets from undo taxation.
Lack of Control Discount: When an heir receives a portion a family-held business that is a minority ownership stake, that portion of the business can be valued lower than a majority ownership share because a willing buyer would not have control over managerial issues. This lack of control makes the minority interest less valuable to a willing buyer than the majority share.
Lack of Marketability Discount: Lack of marketability is an instance in which the interest in a family-held business is not easily convertible to cash. While lack of control does in some instances create a lack of marketability, there are several other reasons an interest cannot be easily sold that reduce the value of the interest. Any barrier to easy liquidation makes an asset, in this case an interest in a family-held business, less valuable to a willing buyer.
Lack of Control or “Minority” Discount
When a family business owner gifts ownership in the company to his or her children, the children typically become “minority” owners. Their shares are worth less to prospective buyers than the majority owner’s shares. The IRS currently grants lack of control discounts as a way of recognizing that the “minority owner” of a family business (one who owns less than 50% of a business) cannot obtain the same price-per-share as the “majority owner” (one who owns more than 50% of a business). Minority discounts allow a minority owner to value their stake at a fair market value, and are taxed at an appropriate level. No family business owner should be forced to pay more in taxes than the price the shares would obtain in the market.
Properties of the Minority Interest:
- Not a controlling interest (in terms of voting).
- Minority discounts range from 15 to 50% (for transfer tax purposes).
- Minority owners do not manage the business.
- Minority owners cannot initiate a sale or liquidation of the business.
- Buyers will pay less for minority interest versus a controlling or majority interest.
Lack of Marketability Discount
Family business owners often place restrictions on the sale of the shares that they gift to their children, in order to ensure that ownership of the business stays within the family. These restrictions – a lack of marketability – reduce the value of the shares. Current law recognizes the reduced value with special discounts for estate tax purposes. Eliminating these reasonable discounts will force family business owners to report higher than market values to the IRS thereby increasing tax liabilities.
The discount for lack of marketability is often the single largest value adjustment business appraisers must consider. This valuation adjustment can exceed 30% in many cases, meaning it’s elimination could artificially increase the value of many taxable estates by 30% or more. The percentage of the adjustment is subjective to the specific circumstances of the business interest and the available market for a possible sale. As a result of its subjective nature, much attention has been given to the lack of marketability discount by the Internal Revenue Service, tax courts, compilers of market data, and business appraisers. These discounts are already subject to IRS scrutiny on individual tax returns.
Proposed changes to Section 2704
Under current rules the fair market value of an interest in a family-held business where no current market is available is based on the “willing-buyer/willing-seller” test; this test establishes a value a willing buyer would pay for that portion of a family-held business. In recent court cases challenging valuation discounts for gift and estate taxes the IRS used significantly higher valuations than CPA firms hired by the family-held businesses often resulting in the IRS seeking larger tax collections.
The proposed rule would disregard any restrictions on liquidation or redemption an heir uses to claim a valuation discount if that restriction either lapses after the transfer or the heir or heir’s family has the ability to remove the restriction after the transfer. An heir, under current law, could claim a lack of marketability discount if there is a restriction on sale of the interest, the proposed rule would eliminate that discount if the heir or their family has the ability to remove that restriction. The proposed rule also eliminates lack of control discounts to assignees.
Family Business Coalition - Letter to Secretary Lew opposing the proposed rule
Family Business Coalition - Valuation Discounts for Family-held Businesses
Wall Street Journal - A Stealth Death Tax Increase
Houston Business Journal - How new IRS rules ‘could be devastating’ for family-owned businesses
Forbes - Treasury To Close Estate Tax Valuation Discounts Loophole, Family Businesses Cry Foul
You can view the comments submitted by the Family Business Coalition here.